Insurance Rates by Car Model
Two drivers with identical records can pay very different amounts simply because of what they drive. Insurance cost by car model comes down to repair cost, theft rate, safety, horsepower and value. This guide explains what makes a model cheap or expensive to insure — and how to check before you buy. Educational only, not a personal quote.
The short answer
What drives model-based rates
Repair · theft · power · value · safety
Cheap-to-fix, hard-to-steal, high-safety models cost less to insure; fast, pricey or frequently-stolen ones cost more. Check before you buy. General patterns, not a quote.
The five things insurers look at in a model
Insurers and the Highway Loss Data Institute track actual claim outcomes for every make, model and trim. Those loss patterns — not the sticker price alone — set the model’s rating. Five factors do most of the work:
| Factor | Effect on rate | Tends to apply to |
|---|---|---|
| Repair & parts cost | Higher | Luxury, imported, EV, aluminum-body |
| Theft rate | Higher | Frequently stolen models & trims |
| Horsepower / type | Higher | Sports cars, performance trims |
| Vehicle value | Higher | Expensive cars (comp/collision) |
| Safety ratings | Lower | Top IIHS/NHTSA scorers |
| Driver demographics | Varies | Models favored by low-risk drivers |
Why repair cost matters more than you’d think
Modern collision repair is dominated by technology. A bumper that once held a foam pad now houses radar sensors, cameras and parking aids, and recalibrating those after a minor fender-bender can cost more than the body work. That’s why two cars with similar prices can have very different collision costs — one may use cheap, widely available parts and simple repairs, while the other needs dealer-only components and specialist labor. Electric vehicles add another wrinkle: battery packs are expensive, and even modest underbody damage can threaten the pack, raising repair and total-loss costs.
Theft and horsepower: the other big movers
Theft data is model-specific and very real to insurers. A handful of popular models have seen theft rates spike in recent years, and their comprehensive costs rose to match. Horsepower and body style matter too — performance trims and sports cars correlate with faster driving and more severe crashes, so they’re rated higher even before you’ve driven aggressively. A turbocharged version of the same car can cost meaningfully more to insure than the base engine.
How to check insurance cost before you buy
The single best money-saving move is to compare insurance before you commit to a car, not after. Narrow your choice to two or three models, then get quotes for each on identical coverage and your own driver profile. The differences can be large enough to change your decision — or at least your budget. You can also check the IIHS/HLDI loss results for a model to see whether it tends to generate more or fewer (and more or less expensive) claims than average. Pair this with our guide to how much car insurance costs and the coverage worksheet so the model you choose fits both your needs and your wallet.
A note on trims and years
Rates vary not just by model but by trim and model year. A base trim with standard safety features can be cheaper to insure than a loaded version of the same vehicle, and a newer model year carries a higher replacement value (raising comp/collision) but often better crash protection and anti-theft tech (helping in other ways). When you request quotes, use the exact trim and year you’re considering — “a Civic” isn’t specific enough to price accurately.
Frequently asked questions
Why do insurance rates differ by car model?
Insurers price each model on its real-world loss data: how often it’s in claims, how much it costs to repair, how likely it is to be stolen, how well it protects occupants, and its value. A model that’s expensive to fix or frequently stolen costs more to insure.
What cars are cheapest to insure?
Typically moderate, popular models with good safety scores, low theft rates and inexpensive parts — many small SUVs, minivans and mainstream sedans. Vehicles favored by safety-conscious, lower-risk drivers also tend to carry lower rates.
What cars are most expensive to insure?
High-horsepower sports cars, luxury vehicles, frequently stolen models, and cars with costly parts or specialized repairs. Electric and high-tech vehicles can also cost more to repair due to batteries and sensors.
Does a more expensive car always cost more to insure?
Usually for comprehensive and collision, since there’s more value to repair or replace — but not always for liability, which depends more on the driver. A pricey car with top safety ratings can sometimes offset part of the cost.
Is this a quote?
No. These are general patterns only. Your cost depends on the specific model plus your profile and insurer. Always get model-specific quotes before buying a car.
Sources & references
Figures and methodology on this page are drawn from the following public sources. Insurance data changes — we note when this page was last reviewed above, and we encourage you to check the latest figures directly.
Related calculators & guides
How Much Is Car Insurance?
What makes car insurance cost more or less, and how to reduce it.
Open →How Much Does Car Insurance Cost?
The factors behind car insurance cost: age, record, coverage, location and car.
Open →Car Insurance Rates by ZIP Code
Why your ZIP code changes car insurance costs, and what to do about it.
Open →How Much Auto Insurance Should I Have?
Decide liability limits and coverages to carry — based on what you have to protect.
Open →Car Insurance Calculator
Choose the auto coverage limits to carry — based on what you need to protect.
Open →